If you’re missing a tooth (or a few), you’re in good company. In fact, according to the American Association of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons (AAOMS), about 69% of adults ages 35 to 44 have lost at least one permanent tooth, and that number rises to 3 out of 4 between the ages of 40 and 64. Fortunately, a lot has changed in the last few decades, and we have more options than ever before to return to a healthy smile.
That said, with so many options, it can sometimes feel daunting to find the right solution. So today, we’ll look at the pros and cons of dental implants vs. dentures vs. bridges, as well as some newer hybrid options. We’ll also explain what’s happening beneath the surface when a tooth is lost.
Why Replace a Missing Tooth?
Unless the missing tooth is noticeable, you may wonder whether replacing it is even necessary. However, that gap isn’t just cosmetic. When you lose a tooth, you lose the root too. And that means the jawbone in that spot no longer gets stimulated as you chew. Because it’s no longer needed, it gradually shrinks, which allows neighboring teeth to drift into the space. Your bite can suffer from the realignment, and over time—especially if you’re missing several teeth—you may even notice your face shape starts to change.
Keep this in mind as we continue, as the effect on the jaw is one of the biggest differences in the options we’ll cover below.
Dental Bridges: The Traditional Fix
A bridge fills the gap with a false tooth anchored to crowns on the teeth on either side, and it’s been a popular option for decades.
Pros:
- Finished in a few weeks
- No surgery
- Lower upfront cost than an implant
- Fixed in place
- Natural-looking
Cons:
- Neighboring teeth have to be filed down to hold the crowns
- Doesn’t replace the root, so the bone under the cap shrinks
- Typically lasts 10 to 15 years, and cleaning under it takes special tools or floss
Best for: A single gap where the neighboring teeth already need crowns.
Dentures: Partial and Full
Removable dentures can replace a few teeth (partials) or a whole arch (full dentures).
Pros:
- Lowest cost upfront
- No surgery
- Works even if there isn’t enough healthy bone to support an implant
Cons:
- They can slip when you talk or eat
- Adhesives, nightly soaking, and sore spots are common complaints
- Less chewing power
- Bone loss continues, so dentures need relining or replacement every several years
Best for: Replacing many teeth on a tighter budget or for patients who aren’t candidates for surgery.
Dental Implants: Replacing Root to Tooth
A dental implant is a small titanium post placed in the jawbone and topped with a custom crown.
Pros:
- The only option that replaces the root as well as the tooth, which helps preserve the jawbone
- Leaves neighboring teeth alone
- Looks, feels, and works just like a natural tooth
- With good care, can last decades—or even a lifetime
Cons
- It comes with the highest upfront cost per tooth
- Requires minor surgery and months of healing
- Some patients need bone grafting first
Best for: Healthy adults with enough bone (or who can rebuild it with grafting) who want the longest-lasting solution.
Implant-Supported Dentures, Full-Arch, and All-on-4
For folks who are missing all or most of their teeth, the right choice may not be between traditional dentures and an implant for each tooth. Instead, a hybrid option may be the best solution. These include:
- Snap-in dentures (aka overdentures), in which a few implants anchor a removable denture. It clicks into place with no adhesive or slippage yet can still be removed for cleaning. If you already wear dentures (and like them), this may be a suitable upgrade.
- Full-arch and All-on-4 permanently attach four or more implants. In many cases, patients can leave with a new set of teeth the same day or within weeks rather than months.
Pros:
- More stable than traditional dentures
- Helps preserve bone and chewing power
- Uses fewer implants than if each tooth were replaced individually
Cons:
- Costs more than traditional dentures
- Requires surgery
Best for: Patients missing most or all of their teeth in an arch or whose remaining teeth are failing and will need to be replaced soon.
| Bridge | Traditional Dentures | Implant-Supported Dentures / All-on-4 | Single Implants | |
| Surgery | No | No | Yes | Yes |
| Treatment time | A few weeks | A few weeks | Same day to several months | Several months |
| Typical lifespan | 10 – 15 years | 5 – 10 years | Decades | Decades or more |
| Protects jawbone? | No | No | Yes | Yes |
| Affects surrounding teeth? | Yes | Partials can | No | No |
| Upfront cost | $$ | $ | $$$ | $$$ per tooth |
| Daily care | Special flossing | Remove and soak to clean | Varies by type | Brush and floss normally |
| Natural feel? | Mostly | Least | Very close | Most |
How to Choose Dental Implants vs. Dentures
There’s no single right answer for every person—there’s only the right answer for you. A few questions to consider with your periodontist include:
- How many teeth are you missing, and where?
- How healthy are your gums and jawbone?
- Are you focused on upfront cost or long-term value?
- Are you comfortable with a minor surgical procedure?
- How much daily maintenance are you willing to commit to?
Why See a Periodontist for Tooth Replacement?
Gum disease is the leading cause of tooth loss in adults. And if left untreated, it can undermine a bridge or an implant. Periodontists specialize in your gums and bones that hold your teeth in place. That means they treat gum disease first, rebuild bone when needed, and place implants with precision—without bouncing you between your dentist and specialists.
Dr. Steven Van Scoyoc is a board-certified periodontist and dental implant surgeon, and Dr. Chandler Conner brings specialty periodontal training to every case. Both of them can help you weigh your options.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I get dental implants if I already wear dentures?
Yes. In fact, implants can either replace your dentures or anchor a new denture so it stays put without the use of adhesives. Implants can also support a fixed full-arch replacement. If, however, you’ve worn dentures for years, you may first need to address any bone loss with bone grafting.
Which lasts longer—a bridge or an implant?
An implant can last decades or even a lifetime, compared to 10 to 15 years for a bridge.
Am I too old for dental implants?
There’s no upper age limit. What matters most is your overall health and bone quality.
Find Your Best Fit in Southern Pines or Sanford
Missing one tooth? Or a full arch? Either way, your journey to a healthy smile starts with a conversation with a trusted periodontist who can help you figure out the best solution for your mouth. Schedule a consultation online or by phone at our Southern Pines office at (910) 692-6270 or our Sanford office at (919) 890-9727. We’ll help you find the tooth replacement option that fits your mouth, your budget, and your life.